California dreaming is fine, but it doesn’t need to end in Texas

by Steve Blum • , ,

Policy statement.

What’s the crazier idea? Inventing a pod that will carry people hundreds of miles through airless tubes at supersonic speeds, or thinking that hundreds of miles of anything can be built in California in the span of, say, a human lifetime?

Even Elon Musk, who unveiled his plans for the former last year, might find the latter beyond his reach, let alone his grasp. Musk has a team of volunteer engineers working on the technology, and by all accounts they haven’t hit a show stopper. Although, to be fair, one of the things they haven’t come to yet is the question of exactly how many billions of dollars are needed to build Musk’s notional prototype Hyperloop line between San Francisco and Los Angeles.

His envisioned route would slice down the Interstate 5 median strip. Yep, all he needs is a hand wave from Caltrans. Yep, the same people who spent 25 years rebuilding half of the Bay Bridge, and who roll up into a fetal position at the mere suggestion that installing tiny plastic tubes — conduit — along highways is a good use of their domain.

And of course, no one could possibly object on environmental or neighborhood serenity grounds.

Anyone with a Silicon Valley pedigree and a major manufacturing plant across the Bay in Fremont – like, oh I don’t know, maybe Musk? – knows that the Silicon Valley BART extension approved by voters in 2000 might – might – make it to south Fremont next year, and won’t make it to Santa Clara before 2025, if then. Compare that eternal 16 mile build to the 72 miles of original BART track built between voter approval in 1962 and start of service ten years later.

So it’s no surprise that the Hyperloop team has sketched out an eventual U.S.-wide network, and Musk has said that the first test track will be built in Texas. If nothing else, the company has floated a shopping list of potential proof of concept routes. Check it out. How about Las Vegas to Phoenix? Or Orlando to Miami? Not to mention the Dallas – Houston – San Antonio triangle, with a stop in uber-cool Austin.

Great ideas begin in California. Implementation, and the jobs and service benefits that go with it, increasingly end elsewhere. We have to welcome both.