CES – the Consumer Electronics Show – opens in Las Vegas next week. Among other things, it’s an opportunity to take a second (or third or fourth…) look at industry segments that held breakout potential at one point, only to fade off into a niche.
MiOS/MiCasaVerde’s Vera 3 multi-mode gateway. No assembly language
required, but you’ll need pretty much everything else.
Home automation is one sector that has never lived up to its hype. Several technologies, notably including the X-10 standard, have been promoted as one-size-fits-all solutions for remote control and monitoring of thermostats, lighting and appliances. Some use existing electrical wiring for connectivity, others are wireless.
Sheer geekiness has been the biggest obstacle to its widespread adoption. No one has come up with a simple and reliable user interface that manages several different kinds of devices. Consumers will embrace a push button that opens and closes a garage door, buy a programmable thermostat and sometimes use it, and even master a four-setting mood lighting switch for the living room. But they won’t tie those functions together or try anything more complicated.
You have to enjoy messing around with gizmos and programming languages to get more out of home automation than you put into it. Changes are are in the works, though.
Second-tier consumer brands, such as Schlage, are starting to offer hosted management platforms that control a limited range of devices via a in-home gateway device and do the heavy geeking on a secure, consumer-friendly website for a monthly fee. Startups, such as MiOS, are developing gateways that can be likewise supported for free or a very low annual cost and are able to manage a broad range of devices and connectivity technologies.
The hosted platforms offer limited choice at a premium price. The newer, more open gateways don’t work well enough to appeal to anyone other than a hobbyist. The missing piece of the puzzle is a clear, consumer-simple economic case that supports subsizing the service, putting serious development resources into cross-platform gateways and provides an incentive for the average homeowner.
That piece might soon be provided by electric utilities. They’ve taken the first step with smart meters which can provide detailed data about energy consumption. The next step is to use that information to control home heating and air conditioning, lights, appliances and entertainment systems. Particularly devices that are either always on but not always needed or use “wall wart” adaptors that constantly draw power.
It’s a Big Brother scenario, but consumers have been willing to trade hands-on control of technology for better performance and lower cost in the past. Cars are maintained by computer chips and datalinks, cable television companies host DVRs and Apple built one of the world’s most valuable brands inside a maximum security walled garden.
The opportunity is on the horizon. Next week we’ll see if anyone is serious about riding out to meet it.